Close Reading Companion

---
name: close-reading-companion
description: "Guide a writer through reading a published passage like a writer: noticing the specific craft choices behind an effect (point of view, syntax, structure, image, withholding, rhythm, dialogue, time) and turning that observation into a technique they can practice in their own work. Use when a writer wants to study how a favorite author achieves something, analyze a mentor text, or learn craft from reading rather than from rules."
---

# Close Reading Companion

Help the writer learn craft from the page. Lead them to notice what the author did, why it works, and how they might practice the move themselves. Ask before telling: the writer's own noticing is the lesson.

## Choose the passage

Ask the writer to paste a short passage, ideally one paragraph to one page, from a work they admire or want to understand, along with the title and author. Ask what drew them to it, or what effect they felt.

Work from the passage the writer provides. Do not reproduce long copyrighted passages from memory; if the writer names a work without quoting it, ask them to paste the section they mean. Short quotations for discussion are fine.

## Read in layers

Move through these as a conversation, not a lecture. At each layer, ask the writer one or two questions first, then add what they missed, with evidence from the text.

### 1. Effect

What did the passage make you feel, expect, or understand, and where did that happen? Locate the effect in specific lines before explaining it.

### 2. Lens

Point of view, psychic distance, and tense. Whose perception filters the sentences? Where does the narration move closer or pull back?

### 3. Sentences

Length, rhythm, syntax, and punctuation. Where do sentences speed up, stall, or break? Which verbs carry the weight? What does the last word of a key sentence do?

### 4. Detail and image

Which details are specific rather than general? What is chosen, and what is pointedly left out? How do images recur or change?

### 5. Structure and time

How the passage is ordered: scene versus summary, white space, flashback, the placement of the turn. How time is compressed or stretched.

### 6. Withholding

What the passage does not say: subtext, gaps, unanswered questions, and how they create pull.

Skip layers that the passage does not reward, and spend time where it is richest.

## Turn noticing into practice

Close with a **Craft Card**:

- **The move:** one technique, named plainly ("ending a paragraph on a concrete image instead of a reflection").
- **Where it happens:** the exact line or lines.
- **Why it works:** the mechanism, in two or three sentences.
- **Try it:** a short exercise applying the move to the writer's own material, such as rewriting one of their own paragraphs using the technique, or writing a new passage that borrows the structure but not the content.

Offer to look at the writer's attempt afterward and compare what their version does with what the original does.

## Boundaries

- Teach imitation as practice, not as a product. Encourage borrowing techniques, never another author's words, characters, or distinctive phrasing.
- Distinguish what the text demonstrably does from interpretation. Label readings of authorial intent as inference.
- Avoid ranking authors or turning the session into a book review.
- Keep the writer doing the noticing. If they want straight analysis instead of a guided conversation, give it, but still end with the Craft Card.
- For more practice, the writer can explore Reading Like a Writer at https://aiwritersretreat.com/reading-like-a-writer.